10 Best Seafood Restaurants in Key West, Florida

Nestled at the southernmost tip of the United States, Key West offers many seafood restaurants. Key West has a wealth of options to indulge in the freshest catches of the sea. From local establishments to upscale waterfront eateries, there is a delightful fusion of flavors, stunning ocean views, and an authentic taste of the coastal culinary heritage. Explore the top seafood dining destinations in this idyllic island city with this article!

Read also:

• Key West’s Top Family-Friendly Things To Do
• Top Hotels and Resorts for Your Next Family Vacation in Key West
• Paradise on a Budget: Affordable Hotels & Resorts in Key West
• The Best Beaches in Key West for Swimming and Snorkeling
• Ultimate 15 Best Things to do in Key West

A&B Lobster House – An Upscale Seafood Restaurant With a Stunning Waterfront View

This elegant establishment is near the historic seaport and is a beloved dining destination for locals and tourists alike. A warm and inviting ambiance with soft lighting, polished wood furnishings, and nautical-themed decor will welcome you to A&B Lobster House.

The main attraction at A&B Lobster House is their delectable lobster dishes. The menu features an array of lobster creations, from classic Maine lobster rolls to rich buttery lobster bisque. The lobsters are fresh from the nearby waters, ensuring the highest quality and flavor.

However, A&B Lobster House offers much more than just lobsters. Their menu boasts a selection of other seafood delicacies, including succulent oysters, shrimp, clams, and fish prepared in different styles. The chefs have culinary skills, expertly combining flavors and textures to create unforgettable dining experiences.

To complement the seafood offerings, there is an extensive wine list featuring a curated selection of wines worldwide. The attentive staff is ready to guide you in choosing the perfect wine to enhance your meal. The restaurant also offers charming outdoor seating to enjoy your meal while enjoying the picturesque harbor views.

• Address: 700 Front St, Key West, FL, United States, Florida
• Open hours: Monday and Thursday, 5:30 pm to 10:00 pm / Tuesday, Wednesday, Friday, Saturday, and Sunday, 5:00 pm to 10:00 pm
• Official website

TourTeller’s Pick! – Food Tours

Half Shell Raw Bar – A Classic Key West Seafood Joint Serving Oysters and Conch Fritters

The Half Shell Raw Bar is a vibrant and lively seafood restaurant that captures the essence of the island’s casual atmosphere. It’s unpretentious charm and friendly ambiance make it a favorite gathering spot.

As you enter the Half Shell Raw Bar, you’ll immediately notice the vibrant energy and bustling activity. The interior has maritime memorabilia, colorful artwork, and a lively bar area where you can mingle, creating a cheerful vibe.

True to its name, the Half Shell Raw Bar is an impressive selection of freshly shucked oysters. These briny delicacies are served on ice, allowing patrons to savor the natural flavors of the sea. It also offers other tantalizing seafood options, such as chilled shrimp, clams, and crab legs, all sourced from local waters to ensure the utmost freshness.

While the raw bar is the show’s star, the Half Shell offers a diverse menu featuring cooked seafood delights. From mouthwatering fish tacos to succulent blackened mahi-mahi sandwiches, there’s something to please every palate. Non-seafood food options, including burgers and salads, are also available, ensuring a dish for everyone.

As you savor your meal, you can enjoy the lively buzz of the restaurant or dine al fresco on the outdoor patio, soaking in the warm Key West sunshine and people-watching as you indulge in your favorite seafood delicacies.

• Address: 231 Margaret St, Key West, FL, United States, Florida
• Open hours: Monday-Saturday 11:00 am to 10:00n pm / Sunday 12:00 pm to 10:00 pm
• Official website

Key West Sunset Sail with Bar & Music

The Stoned Crab – A Seafood Restaurant and Market With Fresh Catch From the Florida Keys

Tucked away in a charming, secluded corner of Key West, The Stoned Crab is a destination for seafood lovers seeking a unique and upscale dining experience. It is in a beautiful historic building, exuding an old-world charm blended with contemporary elegance. With its inviting atmosphere, exceptional service, and commitment to sustainable practices, The Stoned Crab offers an unforgettable culinary journey. Upon entering, you’ll see friendly and attentive staff ready to guide you through the menu and ensure a memorable dining experience.

At the heart of The Stoned Crab’s menu is, of course, the crab. They source the freshest and most sustainably harvested stone crabs, a famous regional delicacy. Served chilled, the stone crab claws are accompanied by delectable dipping sauces, allowing you to savor the sweet, delicate meat at its finest.

While the stone crabs are the show’s star, The Stoned Crab offers an array of other seafood dishes that highlight the flavors of the sea. Each dish is beautifully prepared, from buttery lobster tails to perfectly seared scallops. There are also non-seafood options for those seeking choices.

To complement the exquisite seafood offerings, The Stoned Crab boasts an impressive wine list, showcasing a variety of carefully selected international and domestic wines to enhance the dishes’ flavors. The knowledgeable sommeliers are always on hand to guide you in choosing the perfect pairing. For a truly enchanting dining experience, outdoor seating in a lush tropical garden allows guests to dine under swaying palm trees and twinkling lights.

• Address: 3101 N Roosevelt Blvd, Key West, FL, United States, Florida
• Open hours: 12:00 pm to 9:00 pm daily
• Official website

Check Out Key West’s Dolphin Watch and Snorkel Cruise

Conch Republic Seafood Company – A Casual Seafood Restaurant With a Large Outdoor Patio and Live Music

The Conch Republic Seafood Company embodies the spirit and flavors of Key West, offering a vibrant and lively atmosphere combined with a commitment to serving the freshest seafood the island has to offer. This iconic restaurant pays homage to the region’s rich maritime heritage and captures the essence of the Conch Republic.

Be energized by the lively buzz of conversation and the captivating aromas wafting from the open kitchen. The interior has nautical decor, vibrant colors, and large windows that create a warm and inviting ambiance.

Their menu showcases an impressive selection of seafood dishes, each prepared with meticulous attention to detail. From classic Key West conch fritters to mouthwatering blackened grouper, the sea flavors take center stage. The restaurant takes pride in sourcing its seafood locally, ensuring it has the freshest and most sustainable ingredients.

In addition to the seafood offerings, Conch Republic Seafood Company also offers a variety of land-based dishes, including tender steaks, flavorful chicken dishes, and vegetarian options, ensuring there’s something to please every palate.

It boasts a full-service bar with a selection of spirits, wines, and local craft beers to accompany your meal. The skilled bartenders can whip up a range of signature cocktails, including tropical concoctions and classic favorites.

• Address: 631 Greene St, Key West, FL, United States, Florida
• Open hours: 11:30 am to 9:30 pm daily
• Official website

TourTeller’s Pick! – Snorkeling Trips in Key West

B.O.’s Fish Wagon – A Funky Seafood Shack With an Eclectic Atmosphere and Tasty Fish Sandwiches

Bo’s Fish Wagon is a legendary Key West establishment serving fresh seafood and island vibes since 1989. This quirky and laid-back eatery has become an iconic destination for locals and visitors searching for authentic Key West flavors.

The exterior has colorful graffiti, giving it a distinct and bohemian character. The interior exudes a rustic charm, with weathered wood furnishings, vintage signage, and a relaxed atmosphere that transports you back in time.

Their menu features an array of seafood delights prepared with a no-frills approach. From their famous fish sandwiches, made with locally caught fish and served on fresh Cuban bread, to the succulent shrimp baskets and flavorful conch fritters, each dish is packed with flavor and captures the essence of the island.

In addition to the seafood options, there are non-seafood food items, including juicy burgers, crispy chicken tenders, and vegetarian options. The menu is simple, reflecting the laid-back vibe of the establishment, but the ingredients’ quality and the cooks’ expertise shine through in every bite.

As you savor your meal, you can relax at one of the outdoor picnic tables, immersing yourself in the vibrant street life of Key West. Live music often fills the air, adding to the festive and lively atmosphere that has made Bo’s Fish Wagon a beloved local institution.

• Address:  801 Caroline St, Key West, FL 33040, United States
• Open hours: 7:00 am to 9:00 pm daily
• Official website

TourTeller’s Pick! – Key West Jet Ski Tours

Hogfish Bar and Grill – A Waterside Restaurant Serving Hogfish and Other Fresh Seafood Delights

Tucked away on Stock Island, just a short drive from Key West, Hogfish Bar and Grill is a hidden gem that rewards visitors with a unique dining experience. Known for its fresh seafood, casual ambiance, and waterfront location, this rustic establishment captures the spirit of the Florida Keys. It is along the docks of Safe Harbor Marina, offering patrons sparkling blue water views and picturesque boats bobbing gently in the breeze. The inviting interior complements the laid-back atmosphere, featuring wooden tables, nautical decor, and a friendly staff that exudes the island’s welcoming spirit.

The menu star is undoubtedly the hogfish, a local delicacy often regarded as the “Filet Mignon of the Sea.” The menu also features other seafood options, such as conch chowder, shrimp tacos, and fresh catches of the day.

For those seeking non-seafood choices, Hogfish Bar and Grill offers a selection of land-based dishes, including juicy burgers, savory chicken wings, and hearty salads. The menu caters to diverse tastes while focusing on the fresh and local flavors that make the Keys unique.

As you dine on the outdoor patio, cooled by the ocean breeze, you’ll be transported to a place of relaxation and tranquility. The waterfront setting adds a touch of magic to the experience, making Hogfish Bar and Grill a truly hidden oasis for seafood lovers.

• Address: 6810 Front St, Key West, FL, United States, Florida
• Open hours: Monday, Tuesday, and Saturday 11:00 am to 12;00 am / Wednesday, Thursday, and Sunday 11:00 am to 10:00 pm / Friday 11:00 am to 2:00 am
• Official website

See Key West’s Conch Tour Trains

Louie’s Backyard – A Sophisticated Seafood Restaurant and Lounge With Ocean Views and Live Music

A culinary haven that blends exceptional cuisine, stunning views, and a charming tropical ambiance? It’s Louie’s Backyard! Since its establishment in 1971, Louie’s Backyard has garnered a reputation as one of Key West’s premier fine dining destinations. An enchanting atmosphere combining elegance and a laid-back island vibe awaits you here. The restaurant is in a charming Victorian mansion, exuding old-world charm and sophistication. The interior features stylish decor, intimate lighting, and panoramic windows showcasing breathtaking ocean vistas.

The menu at Louie’s Backyard is a testament to culinary artistry, offering a fusion of flavors and ingredients inspired by the diverse cultural influences of Key West. The talented chefs combine fresh local seafood with international ingredients, creating innovative and enticing dishes that excite the palate. From Caribbean spiny lobster and seared yellowfin tuna to savory duck breast and tender filet mignon, each plate is a work of art, beautifully presented and bursting with flavor.

Louie’s Backyard boasts an extensive wine list featuring a curated selection of fine wines worldwide to complement the exquisite cuisine. The knowledgeable sommeliers are on hand to guide you through the choices, ensuring the perfect pairing for your meal.

The enchantment continues as you venture outdoors to the expansive deck overlooking the ocean. This idyllic setting is perfect for sipping cocktails, enjoying a romantic dinner, or simply reveling in the beauty of the surrounding nature. Louie’s Backyard truly offers a dining experience that is both refined and unforgettable.

• Address: 2305 Laguna Blvd, South Padre Island, TX, United States, Texas
• Open hours: 11:00 am to 2:00 am daily
• Official website

TourTeller’s Pick! – Unique Experiences in Key West

Santiago’s Bodega – A Tapas Bar and Seafood Restaurant With a Cozy Atmosphere and Great Wine Selection

Looking for a vibrant and bustling tapas-style restaurant in Key West’s heart? Head to Santiago’s Bodega! Combining the flavors of Spain with the laid-back charm of the Florida Keys, this eclectic eatery offers an inviting and social dining experience that celebrates the art of sharing good food and great company.

Upon entering Santiago’s Bodega, you’re immediately enveloped in a warm and lively atmosphere. The interior is adorned with colorful artwork, rustic wood furnishings, and dimmed lighting, creating a cozy and convivial ambiance. The restaurant buzzes with energy as patrons gather around large communal tables, engaging in lively conversations and laughter.

The menu at Santiago’s Bodega is a tempting array of small plates or tapas showcasing diverse flavors and culinary influences. From Spanish classics like patatas bravas and jamón ibérico to creative interpretations of international dishes, such as Thai curry mussels and Brazilian-style pork tenderloin, there’s a dish to please every palate. The emphasis on sharing encourages diners to sample a variety of flavors and create a communal dining experience.

To complement the tapas, Santiago’s Bodega offers an extensive selection of wines, craft beers, and signature cocktails. The staff will suggest the perfect libation to enhance the flavors of your chosen dishes.

The friendliness and warmth of Santiago’s Bodega extend to its outdoor patio, where guests can dine under the stars and enjoy the vibrant energy of Key West. With its lively atmosphere, diverse menu, and emphasis on communal dining, Santiago’s Bodega invites you to indulge in a culinary journey that celebrates the joy of good food and shared experiences.

• Address: 207 Petronia St, Key West, FL, United States, Florida
• Open hours: 11:00 am to 10:00 pm daily
• Official website

TourTeller’s Pick! – Eco Tours & Little White House Tour

Eaton Street Seafood Market and Restaurant – A Market and Restaurant With Fresh Seafood and Southern Charm

Nestled in the heart of Key West’s historic district, Eaton Street Seafood Market and Restaurant is a unique establishment that combines a market-style seafood counter with a charming and welcoming dining space. With its commitment to serving the freshest catches from local waters, Eaton Street Seafood Market and Restaurant have become a go-to destination for seafood enthusiasts seeking quality and flavor.

The market counter displays an impressive array of freshly caught seafood, from whole fish and shrimp to oysters, clams, and crab. It allows customers to handpick their desired seafood and prepare it to their liking.

Beyond the market counter, the restaurant offers a cozy dining area where guests can indulge in freshly selected seafood creations. The menu showcases a variety of preparations, from classic favorites like seafood boils and fish and chips to more elevated dishes such as grilled lobster tail and seared scallops. Each dish is expertly prepared, allowing the seafood’s natural flavors to shine.

The friendly staff is knowledgeable about the seafood offerings and happy to provide recommendations or answer any questions you may have.

To enhance your dining experience, the restaurant offers a selection of wines and craft beers, perfectly complementing the seafood flavors. Whether you savor your meal at one of the cozy indoor tables or opt for outdoor seating to enjoy the Key West sunshine, Eaton Street Seafood Market and Restaurant offer a delightful combination of a market-style shopping experience and a delectable seafood feast.

• Address: 801 Eaton St, Key West, FL 33040, United States
• Open hours: 11:00 am to 9:00 pm. daily
• Official website

TourTeller’s Pick! – Key West Bike Tours

Kim’s Kuban – A Seafood Restaurant With a Cuban Twist

Looking for a hidden gem of a restaurant that brings the vibrant flavors of Cuban cuisine to life? Head to Kim Cuban! The tantalizing aroma of spices and slow-cooked meats waft, instantly piquing your curiosity and stirring your appetite. Stepping inside, you’re immediately greeted by the lively ambiance, characterized by the rhythmic beats of salsa music and colorful artwork.

The menu celebrates authentic Cuban dishes. One of their standout offerings is the classic Cuban sandwich, a mouthwatering creation that layers slow-roasted pork, thinly sliced ham, Swiss cheese, pickles, and mustard between two perfectly pressed pieces of Cuban bread. This sandwich’s combination of flavors and textures is truly a delight for the senses.

There is also an array of other traditional Cuban dishes that showcase the island’s rich culinary heritage. From the succulent ropa vieja (shredded beef cooked in a savory tomato sauce) to the fragrant arroz con pollo (chicken and rice), each dish is crafted with authentic flavors and ingredients sourced from local markets.

The black beans and rice, a staple in Cuban cuisine, are cooked to perfection and seasoned with a blend of spices that infuse every bite with a burst of flavor. Sweet plantains, lightly caramelized to achieve a perfect balance of sweetness and tenderness, make for a delightful complement to any main course.

Explore their beverage menu, which includes refreshing options like mojitos, piña coladas, and traditional Cuban coffee. The staff gladly recommends the perfect drink pairing to enhance your meal. They are passionate about sharing Cuba’s vibrant culture and culinary traditions, ensuring each guest feels like a cherished part of the Kim Kuban family.

• Address: 2302 N Roosevelt Blvd, Key West, FL, United States, Florida
• Open hours: Monday-Friday 6:00 am to 5:00 pm / Sunday 6:00 am to 3:00 pm
• Official website

TourTeller’s Pick! – Parasailing & Water Activities

Tips when choosing where to eat the best seafood restaurant

1. Research and Choose Wisely: Look up popular seafood restaurants in Key West and read reviews.
2. Make Reservations: Key West can get busy, especially during peak tourist seasons. Make a reservation in advance!
3. Freshness is Key: When dining in Key West’s best seafood restaurants, prioritize freshness. Opt for establishments that emphasize locally sourced, sustainably caught seafood. Look for daily specials or ask your server for recommendations based on the day’s freshest catches.
4. Daily Specials: Inquire about the restaurant’s daily specials. These dishes often feature the freshest seafood and unique preparations.
5. Local Specialties: Key West has its seafood specialties, such as conch fritters, Key West pink shrimp, and hogfish. Don’t miss the opportunity to try these regional delights.
6. Ask for Recommendations: The staff at seafood restaurants are knowledgeable about the menu. Don’t hesitate to ask for recommendations or their favorite dishes.
7. Seasonings and Sauces: Key West cuisine often incorporates flavorful seasonings and sauces. Explore options like Key lime butter, tropical fruit salsas, and Caribbean spice blends.
8. Freshly Squeezed Key Lime Juice: When ordering dishes that include Key lime, ensure that the restaurant uses freshly squeezed Key lime juice for the authentic flavor.
9. Be Adventurous: Remember to try new seafood varieties or preparations you haven’t had before. Key West’s seafood scene offers a wide range of options to explore.
10. Pair with Local Beverages: Complement your seafood meal with local beverages, such as craft beers from Florida breweries or refreshing tropical cocktails.
11. Outdoor Seating: Many seafood restaurants in Key West offer outdoor seating with beautiful views. If weather permits, opt for a table outside to enjoy the island atmosphere.
12. Save Room for Dessert: Key lime pie is a must-try dessert in Key West. Indulge in this tangy, creamy treat to complete your seafood dining experience.

Check Out Key West’s Aquarium Tickets

Conclusion

In the vibrant culinary landscape of Key West, the best seafood restaurants truly shine as beacons of gastronomic excellence. With their commitment to sourcing the freshest ingredients, crafting innovative dishes, and providing exceptional dining experiences, these establishments have carved a place in the hearts of locals and visitors alike. From the humble fish shacks to the elegant fine-dining establishments, each seafood restaurant in Key West brings its unique character and flavors to the table. Whether you’re savoring succulent shrimp, indulging in a platter of freshly shucked oysters, or sipping on a tropical cocktail while gazing at the azure waters, Key West’s seafood scene promises an unforgettable culinary adventure. So, whether you’re a seafood lover or a curious traveler seeking new culinary horizons, immerse yourself in the vibrant flavors and warm hospitality of the best seafood restaurants in Key West, where the sea’s bounty meets the island’s magic.